How to Prove Selective Enforcement in California HOAs
UPDATED ON NOVEMBER 5, 2025 TO INCLUDE ADDITIONAL SELECTIVE ENFORCEMENT-RELATED Q&As Overview Selective enforcement occurs when HOA boards apply rules inconsistently, punishing some homeowners while overlooking identical violations by others. California law...
Examples of Selective Enforcement in California HOAs: Uneven Rule Enforcement
Overview Selective enforcement occurs when an HOA board applies rules inconsistently, penalizing some homeowners while ignoring identical violations by others. This practice isn’t just unfair, it is illegal under the Davis-Stirling Act (Civil Code 4350). Homeowners...
Selective Enforcement in California HOAs: What It Is and Why It’s Illegal
Overview Selective enforcement occurs when an HOA board applies rules inconsistently, penalizing some homeowners while ignoring identical violations by others. This practice isn’t just unfair. It's illegal under the Davis-Stirling Act (Civil Code 4350). When boards...
Selective Enforcement in California HOAs: What It Is and How Homeowners Can Fight Back
HOW TO CHALLENGE SELECTIVE ENFORCEMENT BY YOUR CALIFORNIA HOA OVERVIEW Selective enforcement is one of the most common and infuriating problems homeowners face in California HOAs. It happens when the board applies the rules...
HOA Reserve Studies in California: Understanding the “Percent Funded” Number
Overview Every HOA in California must prepare a reserve study every three years and disclose a written summary of reserve funding every year. These requirements exist to ensure long-term maintenance and repairs of the HOA’s major components are planned and funded, and...
HOA Recalls in California: How Homeowners Can Remove Their HOA Board
Overview In California, homeowners have the legal right to recall their HOA board of directors. The recall process is designed to give members a practical way to hold boards accountable, but strict rules apply. Success requires meeting signature thresholds, following...
California HOA Issues in 2026: AB 130, Insurance, Special Assessments, ADUs, Recalls
Overview California homeowners are entering 2026 facing overlapping crises: AB 130 fine enforcement, rising insurance costs, mounting special assessments, disputes over ADUs, and recall elections. Each of these issues has the potential to spark conflict, lawsuits, and...
Top 5 HOA Disputes for 2026 in California: AB 130, Insurance, Special Assessments, ADUs, and Recalls
CALIFORNIA HOA FORECAST 2026: THE 5 DISPUTES THAT WILL DOMINATE (AB 130, INSURANCE, SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS, ADUS, RECALLS) OVERVIEW California HOAs are heading into 2026 with unresolved 2024–25 shifts colliding with rising homeowner expectations and limited board...
Can You Hold HOA Board Members Personally Liable in California?
Overview California law generally protects volunteer HOA board members from being sued individually. But those protections are not absolute. When directors cross the line into gross negligence, fraud, abuse of authority, or intentional misconduct, they can lose their...
Can You Sue HOA Board Members in California? What Homeowners Need to Know
YOU CAN HOLD HOA BOARD MEMBERS PERSONALLY LIABLE IN SOME CASES OVERVIEW Few questions come up more often from frustrated homeowners than whether it’s possible to sue individual HOA board members in California. The short answer is that most of the time, California law...
HOA Discrimination, Retaliation, and Harassment in California: Homeowners’ Rights Under Federal and State Law
OVERVIEW California homeowners, including those who live in associations governed by homeowners’ associations (HOAs), are protected against discrimination, retaliation, and harassment by their HOAs under the federal Fair Housing Act (FHA) and California’s Fair...
HOA Retaliation in California: Illegal Board Conduct Explained
Overview California law protects homeowners not only from discrimination by their HOA, but also from retaliation when they assert their rights. Retaliation occurs when an HOA board takes adverse actions against a homeowner because that homeowner filed a complaint,...
HOA Discrimination in California: Fair Housing Act (FHA) and FEHA Protections
Overview Homeowners in California are protected by both federal and state fair housing laws. These laws prohibit homeowners’ associations (HOAs) from discriminating against residents based on race, religion, disability, and other protected characteristics. California...
What Is a Common Interest Development (CID) in California? Definition and Types of HOAs
Overview Most California homeowners who live in a community association are part of a common interest development (CID). A CID is a type of residential community where each owner holds title to an individual unit or lot, while also sharing ownership or usage rights in...
California HOAs and Corporate Law: How the Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Law Applies
Overview Most California HOAs are governed by the Davis–Stirling Common Interest Development Act. At the same time, most, but not all, HOAs governed by the Davis-Stirling Act have chosen to incorporate as nonprofit mutual benefit corporations. Those HOAs are therefore...
HOA Dispute Resolution in California: Mediation, Arbitration, and Litigation Explained
Overview Disputes between California homeowners and their HOAs can be resolved in several different ways. Some conflicts can be addressed informally through Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR), while others must go through Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) before a...
HOA Mediation or Arbitration in California: What Homeowners Need to Know
Overview Disputes between California homeowners and their HOAs can be resolved in several different ways. Some conflicts can be addressed informally through Internal Dispute Resolution (IDR), while others must go through Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) before a...
California HOA Mediation: When ADR Is Mandatory Under Civil Code 5930
Overview Civil Code 5930 requires an offer of Alternative Dispute Resolutions (ADR), typically mediation, before certain HOA enforcement lawsuits are filed. ADR is legally required only in defined situations, and is therefore optional in all others. Regardless, ADR is...
California HOA Small Claims Court or Superior Court: Which Forum Is Right for Your Dispute?
Overview California homeowners facing disputes with their HOA sometimes have a choice: file in small claims court or bring a case in superior court (i.e., a “normal” lawsuit). Each forum has strict limits on what types of cases it can handle. Small claims court is...
California HOAs and Political Signs: What Civil Code 4710 Says About Your Free Speech Rights
TRIGGER WARNING FOLLOWING CHARLIE KIRK'S MURDER TO MY READERS: I wrote this article more than two weeks before the tragic and horrifying events of September 10, 2025, in which Charlie Kirk was murdered. We are deeply saddened and outraged by this cowardly act of...
CONTACT US
MBK Chapman PC can help
OFFICE
120 VANTIS DRIVE, SUITE 500
ALISO VIEJO, CA 92656