Overview

HOA boards in California adopt and enforce rules every day. These rules control homeowner conduct, impose restrictions, and serve as the basis for fines or other enforcement actions. Consequently, the exercise of rulemaking authority frequently fuels disputes between homeowners and their HOAs. These conflicts often center on whether the HOA board possessed the underlying authority to adopt the rule or whether the rule meets the legal standards for enforceability.

HOA rulemaking authority comes from two sources: the governing documents, primarily the CC&Rs, and the Davis-Stirling Act. Those sources define both the scope of what a board may regulate and the process it must follow when adopting or changing rules. When a board exceeds that authority, ignores required procedures, or adopts rules that conflict with governing documents or statutory law, those rules will ultimately not be enforceable, regardless of how the HOA attempts to enforce them.

This Fact Sheet explains how California HOA rules are created, where boards get their authority, and the legal limits that constrain that authority. It breaks down the rulemaking process under Civil Code 4360, including notice and comment requirements, explains how homeowners can challenge or veto new rules under Civil Code 4365, and clarifies the reasonableness standard imposed by Civil Code 4350. It also addresses common misconceptions about what boards can regulate and why many HOA rules fail when tested against California law.

Understanding these limits changes how homeowners evaluate HOA rules. Instead of reacting to enforcement actions, homeowners can determine whether the rule itself is valid and enforceable under California law. [If this topic interests you, try my Fact Sheet, “Can Your HOA Change the Rules Without a Vote? What California Law Actually Says.” Or, you might like “Can My HOA Enforce Rules That Aren’t in the CC&Rs?”]

Key Points

HOA rule disputes are resolved by applying a defined legal framework that governs how rules are created, what they may regulate, and whether they are enforceable. Homeowners who understand that framework can evaluate a rule to determine its legality. The following points explain where HOA rulemaking authority comes from, how HOAs must adopt rules, and the legal limits that determine whether a rule stands or fails in the real world.

• HOA boards cannot adopt rules unless the governing documents grant rulemaking authority. Civil Code 4350(b) requires that any rule an HOA board adopts must fall within the authority that the CC&Rs, Bylaws, or Articles confer. If those documents do not grant the board rulemaking authority, the board has no power to adopt rules at all. This issue rarely arises in practice, however, because the vast majority of California CC&Rs expressly authorize HOA boards to adopt and enforce rules and regulations. But this authority is not automatic, and homeowners must always trace it back to a specific provision in one or more of the governing documents I mention above.
• Where rulemaking authority exists, it is limited by the governing documents and the Davis-Stirling Act. Rulemaking authority is not open-ended, meaning that HOA boards do not have unlimited authority to regulate conduct. Typically, the CC&Rs define the scope of what the HOA board may regulate, and the Davis-Stirling Act (along with other California statutes) imposes additional limits and requirements. An HOA board cannot regulate subjects that fall outside the authority that the governing documents grant, and it cannot adopt rules that conflict with statutory law. For example, if the CC&Rs authorize architectural control over exterior modifications, that authority does not extend to regulating purely interior conduct. Similarly, a rule that conflicts with statutory homeowner rights, such as the right to use drought-resistant landscaping, is not enforceable, regardless of what the rules might say.
• Rules are subordinate to the CC&Rs, Articles, and Bylaws, and thus cannot contradict them. While every HOA in California is governed by a set of documents collectively referred to as the “governing documents,” those documents do not carry equal weight. Instead, Civil Code 4205 establishes a hierarchy among them, with the CC&Rs controlling over the Articles, Bylaws, and rules in the event of a conflict. When a rule imposes a restriction that conflicts with a provision of the CC&Rs, the rule fails. In practice, this typically occurs when bad HOA boards attempt to do an end run around the high threshold that the membership requires to amend the CC&Rs by passing a rule that alters a provision of the CC&Rs. [If you’d like to watch an episode of the podcast, HOA HELL, where Sam and I dive into the hierarchy of the governing documents, watch “How Are CC&Rs, Bylaws, Rules, and Architectural Guidelines Different From Each Other?”]
  • Bad HOA boards often attempt to use rules to avoid the CC&R amendment process. Amending the CC&Rs typically requires high threshold approval from the membership, which can be difficult to obtain. Bad HOA boards sometimes attempt to bypass that process by adopting rules that materially change rights or restrictions that the CC&Rs contain. This approach fails because rules cannot conflict with a higher document, such as the CC&Rs. For example, if the CC&Rs allow Sprinter Vans in the community, the HOA cannot pass a rule banning Sprinter Vans. Or if the CC&Rs ban all recreational vehicles, the HOA cannot pass a rule allowing Sprinter Vans that have been modified to act as recreational vehicles absent a formal vote to amend the CC&Rs.
• Failure to follow the statutory rulemaking process will invalidate the rule. Civil Code 4360 imposes mandatory procedural requirements that HOAs must satisfy before a rule becomes enforceable. The HOA board must first provide general notice of the proposed rule change to the membership and allow a minimum 28-day comment period. After that period expires, the HOA board may adopt the rule at a properly noticed HOA board meeting. Within 15 days after the HOA board adopts the rule, it must provide notice of the rule change to the membership. The rule does not become effective until the HOA board delivers this notice. If the HOA board skips any of the required steps or shortens any of the statutory timelines, the rule is not enforceable.
  • A narrow exception exists for emergency rulemaking. The notice and comment period described above does not apply to rules that the HOA board passes to handle a true emergency. This applies to rules that an HOA board passes to address an imminent threat to public health or safety, or to forestall an imminent risk of substantial monetary loss. In such cases, Civil Code 4360 empowers the HOA board to vote on and pass an emergency rule without notice. Emergency rules, however, are temporary, and they only last a maximum of 120 days (or shorter if the rule provides for a shorter time period).
• Homeowners have a defined statutory mechanism to veto newly adopted rules. Civil Code 4365 allows members to reverse a rule change if they follow a structured process. Members must first deliver a petition signed by at least 5% of the membership requesting a vote to reverse the rule. Once members meet that threshold, the HOA must conduct a membership vote using the same procedures the Davis-Stirling Act requires for HOA board elections. The HOA must hold the vote no sooner than 35 days and no later than 90 days after it receives the petition. If a majority of a quorum of the members (or a greater percentage if specifically required in a superior governing document) votes to veto the rule, the rule is invalidated.
• Every rule must satisfy the reasonableness standard. Civil Code 4350 requires that rules be reasonable, meaning they must rationally relate to a legitimate purpose of the HOA, remain consistent with the governing documents, and apply uniformly. A rule that is arbitrary, discriminatory, or excessively burdensome is not enforceable even if the HOA board had authority and followed the proper procedures. For example, a rule that effectively prevents homeowners from using a feature that the CC&Rs contemplate, such as a balcony or parking space, fails the reasonableness standard because it imposes a restriction that exceeds what is necessary to achieve a legitimate purpose. Similarly, a rule that bans all pets from walking on any common area property (effectively requiring homeowners to carry or drive their pets out of the community to walk them) is unenforceable.
• HOA rules cannot override rights granted by California law. The Davis-Stirling Act and other laws grant homeowners specific rights that rules cannot limit or eliminate. When a rule conflicts with statutory protections, the statutes control. For example, a rule that prevents homeowners from installing solar panels on their roofs, flying an American flag, or owning a dog conflicts with state law and is completely unenforceable.
• Operating rules differ from one-time HOA board decisions. An operating rule applies generally to the entire membership over time, whereas a board decision usually addresses a specific, one-time issue like an architectural application or a disciplinary matter. Homeowners must distinguish between the two because the procedural protections of Civil Code 4360 only apply to the adoption or amendment of operating rules.
• If your HOA seeks to pass or enforce a rule in violation of law, call the HOA attorneys at MBK Chapman. As the leading homeowner-side HOA attorneys in California, MBK Chapman has unsurpassed expertise in identifying and dismantling illegal rules that bad HOA boards attempt to force upon homeowners. Bad HOAs routinely abuse the rulemaking process by passing rules that are unreasonable, discriminatory, or otherwise illegal, often betting that homeowners will not know their rights. If your board is overstepping its authority or ignoring the mandatory statutory rulemaking process, MBK Chapman will help you.

The Davis-Stirling Act provides homeowners with these specific shields to prevent HOA boards from overstepping their authority. By understanding the mandatory timelines and the hierarchy of governing documents, homeowners can ensure their HOA boards remain within the limited confines of the law. When an HOA board ignores these rules, homeowners possess the legal tools to set their HOA straight.

FAQs

About Michael Kushner

Michael Kushner is a California attorney with over 30 years of experience representing homeowners in disputes with their HOAs. He is widely regarded as California’s leading homeowner-side HOA attorney, and has built one of the state’s most prominent law practices dedicated to holding HOAs accountable under the Davis-Stirling Act and California law.

In addition to his law firm’s work, Michael is a recognized lecturer, author, and the host of the hit HOA HELL podcast, where he provides homeowners living in HOA-governed communities with clear, practical strategies for dealing with bad HOAs. He’s also the author of the best-selling book, HOA HELL | California Homeowners’ Definitive Guide to Beating Bad HOAs, which has become a go-to resource for both homeowners seeking real-world solutions to their HOA disputes, as well as those good HOA board members who are interested in doing a good job.

About MBK Chapman Fact Sheets

Homeowners searching for answers online will often come across articles that appear authoritative, but are actually written as search-engine marketing content rather than by an experienced HOA lawyer. These pieces tend to prioritize keyword density over clarity, accuracy, or legal context, which often leaves homeowners more confused than informed.

At MBK Chapman, our Fact Sheets are part of our HOA Law Library and are written by Michael Kushner, an HOA lawyer with decades of hands-on experience representing California homeowners. In fact, Michael Kushner is the HOA lawyer who pioneered the systems and strategies used by some of California’s most successful homeowner-side HOA law firms.

Each Fact Sheet is deliberately concise, statute-based, and designed as a quick-reference guide to help homeowners understand key HOA laws and enforcement rules at a glance.

AND DON’T FORGET TO TUNE INTO MY PODCAST, HOA HELL

YOU CAN ALSO ORDER MY GROUNDBREAKING BOOK

HOA HELL | California Homeowners’ Definitive Guide to Beating Bad HOAs

Amazon  |  Barnes & Noble