Overview

Safety issues in an HOA are not something boards get to ignore or delay. When a homeowner reports a dangerous condition, whether it involves structural problems, lighting failures, water intrusion, or other hazards, the expectation is simple: the HOA investigates and fixes it. When that does not happen, the risk shifts directly onto the homeowners who live there, often with serious consequences.

The Davis-Stirling Act does not treat safety-related complaints as optional. Unless otherwise stated in the CC&Rs, Civil Code 4775 requires HOA boards to maintain, repair, and replace the common areas. When a safety hazard exists in those areas, the HOA must investigate and take appropriate corrective action. In addition, HOA directors must act with reasonable care when issues are brought to their attention, which includes responding to credible reports of dangerous conditions affecting the community.

This Fact Sheet focuses specifically on how the Davis-Stirling Act evaluates HOA inaction when safety issues are involved, and why ignoring those issues creates serious legal exposure for the HOA, and thus each and every homeowner. [If you’d like to learn more about this topic, you might also want to watch an episode of HOA HELL, “Is Your HOA Ignoring Unsafe Common Areas? What the Law Requires in California,” in which my co-host and I delved into this topic in detail. You might also want to read my article, “California HOA Crime and Safety: What Your HOA Must Do About Security.”]

This is the second Fact Sheet in a four-part series. In the first Fact Sheet in this series, “Can a California HOA Ignore Homeowner Complaints?,” I wrote about the broader issue of an HOA’s liability for remaining silent and refusing to act on meaningful homeowner complaints. In the next Fact Sheet, “What If Your California HOA Refuses to Fix Common Area Repairs?,” I’ll cover maintenance, repairs, and replacements that the HOA refuses to perform, and in the last Fact Sheet of the series, “What If Your California HOA Refuses to Enforce Its Own Rules?,” I’ll discuss rule violations that the HOA refuses to enforce and the legal liability that such inaction creates for the HOA.

Key Points

In the vast majority of California HOAs, their boards are responsible for keeping the common areas safe and well maintained. When a homeowner reports a dangerous condition, the HOA must investigate and act. The Davis-Stirling Act requires HOAs to maintain the common areas, and Corporations Code 7231 requires directors to act with reasonable care when those issues are brought to their attention. Those duties do not give HOA boards the option to ignore safety hazards or delay action without consequence.

• Ignoring safety hazards in HOA common areas violates one of the HOA’s most fundamental duties. Unless otherwise stated in the CC&Rs, Civil Code 4775 requires HOA boards to maintain, repair, and replace the common areas. Maintaining the common areas is one of the core functions of any HOA. When a safety hazard exists in those areas, the HOA must take appropriate corrective action. Failing to address known dangerous conditions in the common area constitutes a serious breach of those statutory obligations.
  • Not every reported safety issue is the HOA’s responsibility, but common area hazards almost always are. HOA duties under Civil Code 4775 generally apply to common areas unless the CC&Rs explicitly state otherwise. If a dangerous condition exists within a homeowner’s separate interest, the responsibility may fall on that homeowner instead. The critical question is where the hazard exists and to whom the governing documents assign responsibility. Once a safety issue falls within the HOA’s scope of responsibility, the board must act.
• HOA directors must make reasonable inquiries when a dangerous condition becomes known. Corporations Code 7231 requires directors to act with the care an ordinarily prudent person would exercise in similar circumstances. That duty includes making reasonable inquiries when a homeowner reports a condition that could pose a risk of injury or property damage. HOA directors who ignore or delay action in the face of a credible safety issue not only fail to satisfy that mandatory duty, but they expose themselves to claims of gross negligence, and in more serious cases, breach of fiduciary duty.
• The Business Judgment Rule does not protect inaction in the face of known hazards. Under the Business Judgment Rule (see Corporations Code 7231), courts defer to decisions made by HOA boards when those decisions are informed and made in good faith. That protection depends on the board actually making a decision after reasonable inquiry. When an HOA ignores a reported safety issue and fails to act, however, its directors lose that protection and expose both themselves and the HOA to liability for resulting harm. [If you’d like to learn a little more about when HOA directors lose the benefits of the Business Judgment Rule, read my Fact Sheet “When the Business Judgment Rule Does Not Protect an HOA Board.”]
• Delays in addressing safety issues increase exposure for the HOA and its members. Safety hazards frequently worsen over time and can lead to injury, property damage, or both. When an HOA delays or refuses to act after receiving notice of a dangerous condition, the resulting harm can significantly increase the HOA’s financial exposure, which is ultimately borne by the homeowners through special assessments, de-listing by Fannie Mae, increased insurance premiums, or even loss of coverage altogether.
• Homeowners should document safety complaints and force the issue into the record. Homeowners should report safety issues in writing, identify the specific condition, and preserve all correspondence. Raising the issue at open board meetings and following up in writing helps establish that the HOA had notice of the hazard and failed to act. That record becomes critical if the issue escalates.
• If your HOA ignores safety issues, speak with the expert HOA attorneys at MBK Chapman. Ignoring safety hazards exposes the HOA and its members to serious financial risk. If your HOA refuses to investigate or correct dangerous conditions, call MBK Chapman. Our highly trained HOA lawyers are among the most respected and experienced in the entire state.

When an HOA knows about a dangerous condition and chooses not to act, it is exposing every homeowner in the community to personal risk and liability. If your HOA is ignoring safety problems, that is not something to tolerate or wait out. It is something to address immediately.

FAQs

About MBK Chapman Fact Sheets

Homeowners searching for answers online will often come across articles that appear authoritative, but are actually written as search-engine marketing content rather than by an experienced HOA lawyer. These pieces tend to prioritize keyword density over clarity, accuracy, or legal context, which often leaves homeowners more confused than informed.

At MBK Chapman, our Fact Sheets are part of our HOA Law Library and are written by Michael Kushner, an HOA lawyer with decades of hands-on experience representing California homeowners. In fact, Michael Kushner is the HOA lawyer who pioneered the systems and strategies used by some of California’s most successful homeowner-side HOA law firms.

Each Fact Sheet is deliberately concise, statute-based, and designed as a quick-reference guide to help homeowners understand key HOA laws and enforcement rules at a glance.

AND DON’T FORGET TO TUNE INTO MY PODCAST, HOA HELL

YOU CAN ALSO ORDER MY GROUNDBREAKING BOOK

HOA HELL | California Homeowners’ Definitive Guide to Beating Bad HOAs

Amazon  |  Barnes & Noble